Helping You Regain Control of Your Life Get Started with a Free Consultation
Man at bottom of staircase with a hurt leg

Hurt on a Friend or Neighbor’s Property: Should I Sue?

Brand Peters PC  May 9, 2024

Being injured on a friend's or neighbor's property puts you in a tricky situation. It's an all-too-common scenario where personal relationships and legal obligations intersect, leaving you uncertain about the best course of action, especially if you've experienced damages. 

Despite the dilemma, understanding your rights and the implications of a premises liability claim can guide you toward making an informed decision. Our legal team at Brand Peters PC has the knowledge, experience, and compassion to help you through your unique situation.  

We proudly serve clients in Walnut Creek and throughout Contra Costa County, Alameda County, and Solano County, California. Schedule a free consultation today to get dependable legal guidance.  

Understanding Premises Liability in California

In California, if you're injured on someone else's property because of unsafe conditions, the situation typically falls under premises liability. This legal framework holds property owners in California accountable for injuries that occur on their property, especially if you can prove the property owner was negligent in maintaining a safe environment.  

It's not just about a loose step or an unmarked wet floor. In California, the scope of premises liability can extend to various conditions if negligence leads to your injury. The key points to understand about California premises liability include: 

  • Duty of Care: Property owners have a legal obligation to ensure their property is safe for all visitors. This includes regular inspections and maintenance. 

  • Breach of Duty: If a property owner fails to uphold this duty, and their negligence leads to an injury, they can be held liable. 

  • Types of Visitors: California recognizes different levels of protection for invitees, licensees, and trespassers. Invitees (e.g., customers in a store) are owed the highest duty of care. 

  • Comparative Negligence: In some cases, the injured party may also be found partially at fault, which can affect the compensation received. 

  • Statute of Limitations: There is a limited time frame to file a premises liability lawsuit in California, which is typically two years from the date of injury. 

Understanding these regulations is crucial for successfully filing premises liability claims in California. 

Personal Relationships vs. Legal Rights

Deciding to pursue a lawsuit against a friend or neighbor is undoubtedly difficult. Relationships are valuable, and the thought of causing strain or animosity is often a deterrent. However, it's crucial to remember that injuries can cause significant medical expenses, lost wages, and emotional distress.

California's legal system acknowledges the right to seek compensation for these damages, even when the liable party is someone you know. 

What Are Your Options to Pursue Compensation?

Before deciding on legal action, it's important to explore the alternative avenues that may be available for you to seek compensation. If you've been injured on someone else's property, consider these options: 

  • Open Communication: Directly discussing the issue can unveil solutions that haven't been considered, often leading to mutually beneficial outcomes. It's usually the first step to understanding the other party's perspective and finding common ground. 

  • Filing a Claim with Their Homeowners' Insurance: Homeowners' insurance is not required in California. However, if your friend of neighbor has a valid homeowners' insurance policy, you can file a claim to receive damages with their insurance provider. This can:

    • Avoid Legal Battles: This approach can provide the compensation you need without the stress and confrontation of a lawsuit. 

    • Preserve Relationships: By not taking legal action directly against the individual, you're more likely to maintain a cordial relationship post-resolution. 

    • Shorten Resolution Time: Insurance claims can be resolved more quickly than court cases, meaning you get compensated sooner. 

Considering these alternatives can not only address your needs but also preserve important relationships and save time and resources. Speak with a reliable premises liability attorney to determine all of your options based on your specific circumstances.  

When to Consider Legal Action

While there are many options for avoiding legal action, sometimes filing a lawsuit against a friend or neighbor becomes essential. This can occur when: 

  • Amicable solutions are not feasible

  • The extent of your injuries and associated costs exceed what insurance covers

A premises liability attorney can provide critical guidance on the best course of action while ensuring your rights are fully protected throughout the process. At Brand Peters PC, our team is well-versed in handling premises liability cases, including those involving personal acquaintances like friends or neighbors. We are committed to: 

  • Prioritizing your well-being and financial security

  • Striving to secure the compensation you rightfully deserve

  • Handling your case with the utmost respect for your personal relationships

We understand the delicate nature of these cases and are dedicated to navigating them with sensitivity and professionalism. 

Compassionate Legal Assistance

Injuries on a friend or neighbor’s property can create a complex situation that balances legal rights with personal relationships. It's essential to approach the decision to sue with a clear understanding of your options and the potential impact on your relationships. Consulting with a premises liability attorney can help you make the best decision for your circumstances.  

At Brand Peters PC, we're here to support you through every step, ensuring you're informed, comfortable, and confident in your decision. If you've been injured on a friend's or neighbor's property, contact us today to schedule a consultation. Your well-being is our priority, and we're dedicated to helping you find the right solution.